Kai-Fu Lee, Citron battle heats up

Source:Xinhua Published: 2012-9-6 18:50:19

US short-sellers have been targeting US-listed Chinese companies in the past two years, but now they are running into strong backlash from China led by Internet guru Kai-Fu Lee.

Lee and a group of over 60 executives and investors in China signed a joint statement late Monday, accusing some "China Short-sellers" -- particularly Citron Research -- of "targeting legitimate companies with either no problems or minimal problems" for their own gains.

"Their reports would take advantage of the information asymmetry between China and the United States, and boldly tell lies, knowing that their American readers have no way of verifying them," according to the statement, which was posted on a new website (www.citronfraud.com) created by the group.

The spat was sparked by a Citron report about Chinese Internet company Qihoo 360 Technology Co. that listed on the New York Stock Exchange.

Qihoo 360 makes anti-virus software but also has an online gaming platform, a Web browser and a new Internet search engine business. Zhou Hongyi, chief executive officer of Qihoo 360, was among those who signed the statement.

In one report on Aug. 24, Citron recommended Chinese Internet company Sohu, which operates the Sogou search engine, as a better investment choice than Qihoo 360.

On Aug. 27, Lee published a lengthy rebuttal of Citron's report with a systematic takedown of the company's claims.

"The most ludicrous part of Citron's report is its faulty analysis of search engines and basic misunderstanding of search engine Sogou's strategy and products," wrote Lee, former head of Google China.

He accused Citron of being confusing Sohu's search engine with its Pinyin Input Method Editors (IMEs) businesses, tools used to input Chinese characters via a romanized system.

The report shows that Citron "lacks even the most basic understanding of the Chinese Internet and search engine market, yet it fabricates and distorts information to deceive investors," he said.

"Since Citron has already made big bets on these recommendations before their reports are published, Citron doesn't have to be qualified; Citron's recommendation doesn't have to be right; Citron just needs to mislead their readers to follow their recommendations," Lee wrote.

However, Citron, which refuted Lee's accusations, questioned Lee's motive. In a post on its website, Citron said both Qihoo 360 and its lead investor Sequoia Capital are investors in Lee's Beijing-based technology incubator Innovation Works.

"Is Kai-Fu Lee voicing an objective opinion, or just using his reach on Weibo to support his major investors, regardless of the truth?" the post asked.

In response to Citron, Lee said Qihoo is not an investor in Innovation Works, but the smallest passive corporate investor in a fund that Innovation Works co-manages with about 80 other investors.

The showdown has sparked debate among netizens, with some supporting Lee's stance and others questioning the financial transparency of US-listed Chinese companies.

Short-sellers did help expose fraud and companies with problems, but now they have gone too far to go after innocent companies, a netizen wrote on Sina Weibo, China's most popular microblogging platform.

However, some netizens said that rather than online condemnation, a lawsuit would be the best choice for Chinese companies to protect their legitimate rights and interests.

Short-sellers usually borrow shares to sell them in hopes of buying them back at a lower price, turning a profit from the price difference. Their attacks and relative investigations have triggered a growing wave of Chinese companies delisting from the US stock market.

In a recent case, Focus Media, a Chinese outdoor advertising group, announced last month that it planned to delist itself from NASDAQ in a deal potentially worth 3.5 billion US dollars offered by a group of equity fund managers.

Focus Media's shares were hit hard last year following a negative review released by short-selling firm Muddy Waters.



Posted in: IT

blog comments powered by Disqus