
Illustration: Lu Ting/GT
By Qiu Chen
When asked whether he liked his mother or father best, 3-year-old Pengpeng was quick to respond. "Neither. My grandma!" he replied loud and clear while playing in his neighborhood on a Saturday afternoon. Standing nearby was his grandmother, 56-year-old Zhang Xiuqin who was keeping an eye on him. In one hand she held a bottle of water and in the other hand she held a small towel to wipe off his sweat.
"His father went to the gym and his mother went to dance," Zhang told the Global Times. "They are busy during the week, so I think they deserve an easy weekend to relax." To lighten the young couple's burden, Zhang said she retired early at 52 to look after their child. She cooks for him, puts him to bed, and takes him to and from kindergarten. "When Pengpeng started talking, the first word he said was not 'mama' or 'dada' but 'grandma,'" Zhang said proudly.
Pengpeng is not the only child who spends more time with his grandmother than his parents. The phenomenon can be seen nationwide. According to a survey conducted by the Sociology Department of Fudan University in 2007, in China over 60 percent of preschool children are looked after by their grandparents. In China, there is no social stigma for working parents to send their child to live with a grandparent during the week. Also, because of China's one-child policy, children of parents who were born after the 1980s have four devoted grandparents to take care of them.
Childcare choices
In Shanghai, grandparents have become the main source of childcare. A survey conducted by the Shanghai Municipal Population and Family Planning Commission found that around 90 percent of kids under 3 years of age are being looked after by at least one grandparent. The trend is so common that when the city government did an inquiry on early childhood education in Changning district last year, they chose to interview grandparents, rather than parents, about early education options.
Only 31.5 percent of grandparents in Changning district believe their grandchild needs an early education. The rest of those surveyed, almost 70 percent, chose eating and sleeping over education as the most important factors in a child's early development.
This result of the inquiry triggered concern over the problem behind grandparent childcare. "Instead of taking it for granted and leaving our children to our parents, maybe we young parents should think about what the actual cost is. It costs our parents their retirement, it may cost our children early education opportunities or more," said Zhang Wei, a 32-year-old father of a 5-year-old daughter. He told the Global Times that his daughter is raised mainly by him and his wife, which he believes is the main reason his daughter is not as self-indulgent and selfish when compared to his cousin's child who is brought up by his grandparents.
Zhang said when his cousin's child wanted to watch television, the 7-year-old grabs the remote and changes the channel to what he wants to watch regardless of how many people are watching television. "It seems that his world revolves only around himself. He shows no care or thought for others," Zhang said. In contrast, Zhang's daughter, though younger than the boy, helps her parents with the household chores.
Zhang said his cousin feels at a loss when dealing with his son. "My cousin's family lives with his parents. The boy is looked after by his grandparents when my cousin and his wife are at work. When my cousin sets a rule for the boy, the grandparents allow the boy to break it the next day," Zhang said.
"Selfish, self-indulgent, stubborn and shameless," are the words 26-year-old Su used to describe her 16-month-old daughter. The Wuhan native sent her daughter to her hometown, where she can be taken care of by four grandparents. "Now I regret my decision. My daughter has been spoiled and I find it impossible to change her behavior," Su said.
Parents are important
According to associate professor of the School of Psychological and Cognitive Science at East China Normal University, Yan Wenhua, birth until 5 years old is a crucial period in a child's psychological development. "If they are spoiled during that period, they are more likely to be narrow-minded, irresponsible and self-centered adults," she said. "Grandparents are in a later period of life, which makes them less active and more concerned about safety. So they tend to protect the child. For example, if a child falls down, they will run to help him or her instead of telling the child to rely on his or her own strength to stand up. It is bad for cultivating the child's independence."
Yan also mentioned, if a child grows up with his or her grandparents at an early age, they are more likely to rebel against their parents when they reach adolescence. "If children rarely feel love or care from their parents before 10 when they are desperate to feel close to their parents, the parent-child relationship will suffer. Children are more likely to distrust their parents and ignore their advice when they are older," Yan said.
But it is not necessarily bad for grandparents to look after the child, said 30-year-old mother Yang Li, whose parents and in-laws take care of her 3-year-old daughter during the day. "As far as I am concerned, everything goes well for my daughter. She now learns to recite Tang poetry with the help of her grandparents," Yang said. "Thanks to them, my husband and I can go to work without worry. After all, her grandparents care for her much better than a nanny would. After we get off from work, my husband and I try to spend as much time as possible with our daughter. We are glad to see that she is close to us and our parents."
On the contrary, another young mother surnamed Zhao said she has problems raising her daughter with her in-laws. "Often, after I set one rule for the girl, the grandparents could allow her to break it," Zhao said. "My daughter Juanjuan smashes things whenever she feels unsatisfied. I always ask her to pick them up by herself, but my in-laws do it for her every time. When I insist that she do it, they say that it is not a big deal, and good behavior will form naturally during the child's development. We've talked to them about it several times, but it is hard to change their deep-seated beliefs in childcare."
According to Yan, it is natural for the two generations to have different attitudes towards childcare. "For grandparents, childcare is mainly about eating right and sleeping well. Because when these grandparents were children 50 or 60 years ago, parents struggled to keep them alive, and when they were parents, they had to work hard to buy their children something good to eat," Yan said. "However, for younger parents, especially those who are influenced by modern attitudes to raising children, they are more aware of the need to educate children at an early stage."
These differences make communication all the more important when people from different generations raise children together, according to Yan. Yan suggested that parents should solely raise their child by themselves if they fail to reach an agreement on how to educate the child with the grandparents. "If one child is guided or taught by two different rules, he or she will become confused, and act differently when he or she is with different people, which makes it harder for the child to develop good habits."
According to a teacher surnamed Chen who works at Dongchang Road Elementary School, a second grade student in her class refuses to do his homework whenever his father is away on business. "He is raised mainly by his grandparents, who spoil the boy so much that he seldom listens to them. When his father is at home, the boy behaves well and acts like a different person. But once the parents are away, he reverts back to a 'little emperor,' leaving his grandparents feeling totally helpless," Chen said.
Yan added that without satisfactory communication, conflicts caused over differing views on childcare would happen not only between the older and the younger generation, but also between both sides of the family.
Grandparents at fault
Last year, in Changzhou, Jiangsu Province, a paternal grandfather surnamed Wang killed his grandson's other grandfather surnamed Chen in a fight about who should raise the 3-year-old. According to Yangtze Evening News, there had been an ongoing argument about how to educate the boy between both sides of the family. One day when Wang saw Chen riding a motorbike with his grandson, he stopped them and forced Chen to bring the child to his home. Afterwards Chen argued with him and Wang stabbed him to death.
In response to criticism from both society and their children, some grandparents feel it is unfair. "It is not an easy job raising a child," Zhang Xiuqin said. "My grandson is high-spirited, so running after him would soon wear me down. Moreover, the possibility of something wrong happening always hangs over me. When he is playing, I worry about whether he will fall. When he is eating, I am anxious about what I should do if he could not digest the food. Most importantly, I'm afraid if something wrong does happen, my children especially my daughter-in-law would blame me and not allow me to look after him."
Recently in China there has been much concern over who is responsible for a child's safety. A tragedy that happened in Beijing in 2009 caused heated discussion about this issue. According to the Beijing News, 3-year-old Lele fell from 12th floor to his death after he climbed out of the apartment's window, when his maternal grandfather Zhang Xiang, who looked after him, was taking a nap. Soon after, Lele's father Li Jian divorced his wife and sued Zhang, demanding 300,000 yuan ($45,885) in compensation for psychological injuries. However, the court ruled it was an accident and that Zhang had to pay his ex-son-in-law 10,000 yuan in damages.
According to Wang Yiwei, a member of the Beijing Lawyer's Association and commissioner of the Special Committee for the Protection of Minors, when parents send a child to a grandparent who agrees to look after the child, according to the law, parents have entrusted the role of guardian to the grandparent, even though no contract or pay is involved. Among the duties, the most important is to safeguard the child. But since grandparents are not legally obliged to care for the child, they only bear fault liability, which means they are only responsible for a child's injury or death when conscious neglect is proven.
As for Zhang Xiang's case, Wang Yiwei told Beijing Evening News, some lawyers believe it was Zhang's negligence that led to the tragedy, as he left a restless 3-year-old to play by himself and opened the window wide.
"But who can guarantee absolute safety for the child? If a person becomes liable for any mistakes he or she makes, who would dare to look after a child?" said Zhang Xiuqin, who showed her support to Zhang Xiang. "The father shifted his responsibility to his ex-father-in-law and forced the old man to bear all the risk. This is a cruel reaction to a grandfather who sacrificed his golden years to care for his grandson," Zhang Xiuqin said.
The second part of this report on grandparents and childcare will appear on April 21.