Growing pains: Post-Brexit ‘protocol’ stunts N.Irish business
Empty promises
Published: May 24, 2021 08:28 PM
Five months after the UK cut ties with the European Union, the post-Brexit "protocol" governing Northern Irish trade is sowing discontent in the province.

Owner, Robin Mercer, poses amongst flowering plants in a greenhouse at Hillmount Garden Centre in East Belfast, the UK, on Wednesday. Photo: AFP

Owner, Robin Mercer, poses amongst flowering plants in a greenhouse at Hillmount Garden Centre in East Belfast, the UK, on Wednesday. Photo: AFP

"Traditionally a box of seeds would take us four days to get from England to Northern Ireland," said Robin Mercer, owner of Hillmount Garden Centre in Belfast.

"It's taking four weeks now because of the paperwork involved," he told AFP. "And it costs 140 pounds ($200) for a box of seeds whether there's 400 pounds' [worth] in the box or 600 pounds."

Britain officially left the EU in January 2020, but under the terms of the divorce, relations remained unchanged until the start of 2021.

Since then, London and Brussels have been trading on new terms, effectively keeping Northern Ireland in the EU customs union and single market for goods.

The tailored arrangements are designed to sustain Northern Ireland's fragile peace but for Mercer - who operates three garden centers east of Belfast - it has undermined business.

"The protocol, it needs to be abolished," he said.

Troubled ground 

Some 3,500 people were killed in violence over British rule in Northern Ireland, including at the border with the Republic of Ireland.

A 1998 peace deal ended the unrest between pro-UK unionists and pro-Ireland republicans, and border infrastructure was removed as British troops withdrew. 

But the 500-kilometer frontier with EU member Ireland posed a problem as Brexit approached, as it is the UK's only land border with the EU.

The border was easy enough to keep open with both sides inside the EU. But with one in and the other now out, the prospect of checks and policing on goods in transit caused alarm in Dublin, Belfast, and Brussels, and with that fears of fresh unrest.

The "Northern Ireland Protocol" instead shifted the necessary checks to Northern Irish seaports on goods arriving from mainland Britain - England, Scotland, and Wales.

Protocol pains 

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson promised "emphatically" that trade between mainland Britain and Northern Ireland would remain unfettered. But Mercer, who employs about 70 members of staff, said that has not happened.

New paperwork required to ship goods across what is effectively the EU border is costing businesses time and money - and compounding stress caused by the coronavirus disease pandemic.

"Getting stock in has been a total nightmare. We have still not had one plant in from England," said Mercer.

Ulster University has predicted that economic output in Northern Ireland in 2020 would fall by as much as 9.6 percent as a result of the global health crisis.

Purchases and imports into Northern Ireland from mainland Britain vastly outweighed those arriving from Ireland and the rest of the bloc, according to official figures from 2018. 

But that may be changing, according to Mercer.

"None of the hauliers are prepared to do the paperwork and all of the hold-ups. We've actually had to start buying plants from Europe," he said.


Garden centers are not alone in suffering setbacks in Northern Ireland, which already has the lowest GDP of any UK region.

In the first weeks of 2021, some Northern Irish supermarkets saw food shortages, as suppliers grappled with new import rules. 

Pressured by disruption, London made unilateral moves to delay until October the introduction of full custom controls on goods arriving in the province from mainland Britain.

That prompted legal action from Brussels. But Mercer fears worse is to come, amid mounting calls from politicians for the situation to be resolved.

"This is the relaxed period as far as it goes with all the rules and regulations," he said. "At the end of the year, they're going to start enforcing them more."

In February, graffiti threatening port staff manning the new checkpoints caused protocol inspections to be suspended at Belfast and Larne ports.

More worryingly, the rhetoric around the protocol was at the center of unrest in unionist communities in April, fearful that the "Irish Sea border" could end their place in the UK.

"We can't have a difference in our status between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK without our consent, and we do not consent to it," David Campbell of the Loyalist Communities Council said on Wednesday.

"No other country in the world would tolerate suppliers having to issue customs declarations to move goods from one part of its own territory to the other," he told UK lawmakers.

"Why on earth would it ever be acceptable in the United Kingdom?"
blog comments powered by Disqus