Will the curse of ‘Dune’ be lifted in Venice?
High hopes
Published: Aug 29, 2021 05:53 PM
Promotional material for <em>Dune</em> Photos: Courtesy of Maoyan

Promotional material for Dune Photo: Courtesy of Maoyan

Promotional material for <em>Dune</em> Photos: Courtesy of Maoyan

Promotional material for Dune Photo: Courtesy of Maoyan

With a $16 million budget and a cast to rival the star system of Arrakis, hopes are high for Dune as it prepares to land in Venice on Friday for its world premiere.  

The cast list is exciting enough, including Timothee Chalamet, Zendaya, Jason Momoa, Oscar Isaac and Javier Bardem.

But what has sci-fi fans really feverish is the man behind the camera: Canadian Denis Villeneuve. 

Through hits like Sicario and Arrival, Villeneuve has put himself alongside Christopher Nolan as one of the rare directors who can deliver deadly serious cinema that also packs theaters. 

Crucially, he has also proved a safe pair of hands when handling totems of 20th-century geekdom, after his critically adored Blade Runner 2049, a sequel to the sci-fi classic.

A prototype

Set many millennia in the future, Dune follows the tribal battles for control of "spice," a drug that extends life and delivers prophetic powers, on the inhospitable planet of Arrakis, which also happens to be infested with giant worms.

The brainchild of author Frank Herbert, Dune was first published in 1965 and became a six-volume space opera of massive influence, not least on Star Wars.

"It is the biggest-selling and most-read science fiction novel ever, but also the most commented upon and the most studied," said Renaud Guillemin, an eminent member of France's community of "Duniens."

"It was the prototype for the sort of world-building universe in science fiction books, with their own coherence, references and foundations," said Guillemain, comparing it to what Lord of the Rings did for fantasy. 

Some of the images and ideas have also become sci-fi staples, including its giant sandworms (hello Tremors), suits that recycle sweat, or the Bene Gesserit, an order of female martial arts experts with thought-control powers. 

Fans also praise its visionary edge, anticipating debates over global warming and the impact of technology. 


Despite its ready-made audience and clear cinematic potential, previous transfers to film have been famously difficult. 

"It is cursed by its excellence," said Lloyd Chery, author of a French reference book about Dune

Cult Franco-Chilean filmmaker Alejandro Jodorowsky was the first to try his hand, spending no less than four years in the 1970s on the project, with Salvador Dali, Alain Delon and Orson Welles lined up, along with Pink Floyd for the music. 

In the end, the money could not match the ambition and it became part of tragic movie lore, recounted in the 2013 documentary Jodorowsky's Dune.

In the 1980s, in the wake of Star Wars, studios grew more interested.

Fresh from Alien, Ridley Scott was tapped to direct, before it was passed to David Lynch. 

Seven versions of the script and six punishing months filming in Mexico led to many monumental sets being built and thousands of costumes. 

But Lynch's mad vision was fatally undermined by the Hollywood machine, and the movie bombed on release in 1984.

A trilogy?

There have been popular TV adaptations since, including Children of Dune starring James McAvoy, but never on the grand scale that the novels seemed to demand. 

Cue Villeneuve, and his all-star cast.

Far from the "nightmare" experienced by Lynch, he appears over the moon with his film, and is already thinking about two possible sequels, according to an interview he gave CBC Radio Canada. 

But that will depend on the commercial success of the first installment. 

Villeneuve has already clashed with Warner Bros over its decision to release the film on streaming platforms alongside the theater release. 

"There is absolutely no love for cinema, nor for the audience here. It is all about the survival of a telecom mammoth," Villeneuve said in a statement about the decision in December 2020. 

While that clash plays out in Hollywood boardrooms, all eyes will turn to the battles on Arrakis when Dune premiers on Friday. 

After a low-key event in 2020 due to the pandemic, La Mostra is raising the stakes once again in the battle for film fest supremacy with the sort of lineup that has drool running down the chins of red carpet gawkers and pretentious film critics alike, cementing its status as a serious rival to Cannes.

The world's oldest film festival has embraced Hollywood in recent years and its 78th edition, running from Wednesday to September 11, is no exception.

blog comments powered by Disqus